In your state, you are required to confirm you wish to access this information. Please enter 'QLD' or 'WA' in the field below to continue.

No thanks

Pregnant and unreliable: A preposterous case of dismissal


Earlier this month, a Melbourne real-estate firm was slammed for firing administrative assistant, Ms Mahajan, on grounds she was ‘unreliable’. The true justification for her firing came to light when her case made it to the Federal Circuit Court; she was pregnant, and had taken time off for morning sickness.

No grounds for termination

Luckily, the law was on the employee’s side, with Judge Riley finding the behaviour of the firm absolutely ‘preposterous’. The real estate agent argued Ms Mahajan’s tardiness was to blame, yet the court found she was only ‘five to ten minutes late’ on a handful of occasions, and made up for this time at the end of her day. Apart from this, her only absences were under entitled annual and personal leave.

Outrageous as Ms Mahajan’s case may appear, Shine Lawyers’ Consumer Disputes Special Counsel Will Barsby says that unfortunately, this kind of case is all too common. “Tiffany’s case is really one that we shouldn’t be having a discussion about in 2017,” Will noted.

Your rights, entitlements and protections as an employee

Strong protections exist under Australia’s employment law scheme that protect employees, such as Ms Mahajan, from being terminated for reasons that are harsh, unjust or unreasonable, or for exercising an entitled workplace right.


All employees are granted with certain entitlements that cannot be infringed by their employer. For young mothers that have been with their employer for over 12 months, there is a right to take maternity leave once the child is born or after adoption, and an employee cannot be persecuted for being ‘unreliable’ because of this.

If Ms Mahajan’s story sounds all too familiar, there is a chance that you, or a loved one, may have a claim for unfair dismissal or for breach of a general employee protection.  “You have to understand the reasons why you have been fired” Will explains. “Then, it’s really about that gut feeling test.”

A strict 21-day time limitation applies for unfair dismissal claims, so if you’re concerned about the circumstances surrounding your termination, it is best to seek expert legal advice as soon as possible.


Written by Shine Lawyers on . Last modified: September 6, 2017.

Join the discussion

Share this article:

There are 0 comments. Be the first!

Fruit pickers, take note

Come harvest time, most Australian farmers are desperate for good workers.  For backpackers fruit picking is a relatively easy job to secure between December and July, but the work itself is far from a walk in the park.  Days are long, with repetitive and physically demanding tasks in very hot and humid conditions. Backpackers, know […]

Read more

Don’t let redundancy ruin your Christmas

With just under two months until Christmas, an unfortunate reality is that this time can bring uncertainty around the security of your employment. Big and small businesses sometimes approach this time of year as a time to reduce costs and people headcounts, looking to start the year fresh. The festive season often sees a spike […]

Read more

Mental health in the workplace: Australian Federal Police officers speak out

Members of the Australian Federal Police (AFP) have recently started to stand up and speak out. Tales of inadequate institutional support for workplace bullying and mental health issues are coming forward. Almost 100 officers both past and present have spoken out on what has been called the AFP’s “disturbing bullying culture”. With incidents of workplace […]

Read more

Gender Pay Gap – Why does it still exist?

Enough with the quotas and the equality policies, why is the gender pay gap still a “thing” in 2017? There are some who deny the gender pay gap exists but as it turns out we have all been eye witnesses to it. Every week day morning. For a decade. What exactly does Karl Stefanovic have […]

Read more

Call Us Now

Our friendly consultants are available to talk Monday to Friday, 8:15am to 6:00pm AEST.

1800 618 851

Live Chat

Chat with Shine Lawyers through the livechat system without leaving your computer. No downloading, completely private and best of all - its easy to use.

Start a live chat now

Enquire Now

Enquire now