Are you in VIC? If not, please change below.

In your state, you are required to confirm you wish to access this information. Please enter 'QLD' or 'WA' in the field below to continue.

No thanks

Road Safety and Speed Cameras: Should an Alternative be Utilised?

Modern speed camera | Shine Lawyers

Speeding is the biggest killer on our roads, according to the NSW Centre for Road Safety, accounting for around 40% of road deaths. But are speed cameras the best way to deal with the problem or should we be looking at alternative options?

Caradvice.com.au has stated that in financial year 2017, speed cameras in Australia raised a huge 1.1 billion dollars.

In January 2018, Queensland Police Union President Ian Leavers said that speed cameras were “revenue raising”.

But not everyone agrees. The WA Police Force states on their website: “the Western Australia Police does not want to fine you, they simply want you to slow down. All of the money collected from speed and redlight camera infringements goes into the Road Trauma Trust Fund and is spent on various road safety programs.”

So how do speed cameras work? What are their benefits? And are there alternatives that may suit the public better?

How Speed Cameras Work

Fixed speed cameras are in a permanent location, usually attached to a pole or bridge. Mobile speed cameras are operated by a police officer from the roadside.

When a vehicle exceeds the speed limit, a photographic detection device is activated. The device takes a photograph of either the front or rear of the vehicle. Time, date, location and the posted and detected speed are also collected along with the image.

Point-to-point speed cameras calculate the time it takes a car to travel from one camera to the next, comparing the average speed between the two cameras with the speed limit of the road.

(https://www.police.qld.gov.au/programs/roadSafety/infringement/speedcameras.htm)

Benefits

The money raised from speed camera fines goes toward initiatives including safer road improvements, senior school road safety programs and road safety education and awareness, among other things.

The website towardszero.net states that cameras save lives, claiming “there has been a 47% reduction in crashes resulting in death or injury at Victorian intersections fitted with a safety camera”.

Alternatives

In an article for Conservative Home, Geoff Luxford suggested improvements to road layout and signage as an alternative to speed cameras, which he argued were often “targeted in conditions where a moderate excess speed, over an arbitrary limit, is of no danger to anyone”.

An article published by the Telegraph said that trees were shown to be as effective as speed cameras in an experiment in four villages. It showed that motorists slowed down due to “a cut in their peripheral vision”.

In 2016, Russell White, CEO of the Australian Road Safety Foundation, said “we need to look beyond speed cameras”. He has taught “after-licence driver training” for two decades and said drivers should “never stop learning”.

He also suggested we start driver retesting for older drivers at an earlier age. While some Australian states only require re-testing at the age of 85+, it might be useful to start around 65+.

Contact Us

If you or a loved one have been injured in a car crash, Shine Lawyers can help you make a compensation claim on a “no win, no fee” basis. Find out more at https://www.shine.com.au/service/motor-vehicle-accidents/car-accident-lawyers.

Written by Shine Lawyers on . Last modified: June 7, 2018.

Join the discussion

Share this article:

  • Laurie Peninton wrote:

    I would say, people falling to sleep when driving is the biggest killer. It would look like speeding when it is not, just people going to sleep when driving. I travel hundreds of kilometers a week and see many signs of people running off the road for no reason and the only explanation I can come up with, is that they are falling to sleep when driving. I see drowsy drivers on the road and that could cause speeding.

  • Cyclists to benefit from new TAC changes

    All cyclists in Victoria who are injured in accidents involving stationary vehicles will now be able to access compensation. Under new legislation introduced by the Andrews Labor government, cyclists will be able to access Transport Accident Commission (TAC) benefits if they are injured at any time by a moving vehicle, a stationary vehicle or a […]

    Read more

    Your Rights and Responsibilities as a Pedestrian

    Pedestrians make up the largest group of road users, simply because we are all pedestrians at some point – whether walking for fitness or leisure, going to work, heading to school or the local shops or walking to access public transport. [1] According to the most recent Road trauma Australia statistical summary, there were 1,768 […]

    Read more

    Motorcycles and Lane Filtering: Is it legal in Australia?

    Motorcycles and Lane Filtering: Is it legal in Australia? Lane filtering is the act of slowly riding a motorcycle between two rows of slow-moving or stationary vehicles heading in the same direction as you. If you’re a motorbike rider, you’ve probably lane filtered before. If you’re not, it’s very likely you’ve seen lane filtering in […]

    Read more

    Car Safety: How safe is yours, and how far have we come?

    Wondering how safe your car is? You might be encouraged (or discouraged) to know that the more recent the model of your car, the safer it’s likely to be. While the road is still a dangerous place– there were 1,127 road deaths in 2017 – manufacturers are constantly working on new ways to improve safety […]

    Read more